Insurance - Property & Casualty stocks, ranked

Live ranking of 14 Insurance - Property & Casualty stocks by TickerMover Quant Score — a 0-100 composite of fundamentals, valuation, momentum, analyst signal, and macro regime. Click any ticker for the full breakdown.

Scores are spread about as widely as the universe overall. These are descriptive measures of the group as it stands today, not a forecast and not a recommendation.

Ticker	Grade	Score	Bottom line
THG The Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.	A	72	Top-tier setup — 4/4 EPS beats. Momentum, fundamentals and macro indicators are aligned.
AFG American Financial Group, Inc.	A	72	Top-tier setup — 3/4 EPS beats. Momentum, fundamentals and macro indicators are aligned.
AIZ Assurant, Inc.	A	71	Top-tier setup — 4/4 EPS beats. Momentum, fundamentals and macro indicators are aligned.
RLI RLI Corp.	A	71	Top-tier setup — 4/4 EPS beats, 22% net margin. Caveat: trades 5.9% above analyst mean target. Stock is trading above the analyst mean target ($60) — limited consensus headroom.
KNSL Kinsale Capital Group, Inc.	A	71	Top-tier setup — 4/4 EPS beats, 28% net margin. Caveat: trades 6.9% above analyst mean target. Stock is trading above the analyst mean target ($355) — limited consensus headroom.
ALL The Allstate Corporation	B	67	Solid setup — 4/4 EPS beats. Momentum, fundamentals and macro indicators are aligned.
TRV The Travelers Companies, Inc.	B	65	Solid setup — 4/4 EPS beats. Caveat: trades 2.6% above analyst mean target. Stock is trading above the analyst mean target ($360) — limited consensus headroom.
CINF Cincinnati Financial Corporation	B	64	Solid setup — 32% revenue growth, 3/4 EPS beats, 24% net margin. Momentum, fundamentals and macro indicators are aligned.
ORI Old Republic International Corporation	B	62	Setup looks favourable on the available data. Momentum, fundamentals and macro indicators are aligned.
PGR The Progressive Corporation	B	61	Solid setup — 3/4 EPS beats. Momentum, fundamentals and macro indicators are aligned.
SIGI Selective Insurance Group, Inc.	B	61	Setup looks favourable on the available data. Momentum, fundamentals and macro indicators are aligned.
CB Chubb Limited	C	57	Mixed signals — neither side has the edge here. The thesis lacks a clear edge from current data.
L Loews Corporation	C	53	Mixed signals — neither side has the edge here. The thesis lacks a clear edge from current data.
WRB W. R. Berkley Corporation	C	51	Mixed signals — neither side has the edge here. The thesis lacks a clear edge from current data.

Quant Scores update every 5 minutes during US market hours. Grades: A Top Tier · B Quality · C Average · D Below Avg · F Weak. (Quality descriptors, not buy/sell recommendations.)